April 18, 2024

Melbourne hospital given right to administer transfusion without consent

A pregnant Jehovah’s Witness teenager had refused the procedure

A court in Melbourne, Australia, has approved a hospital’s request to administer a blood transfusion to a pregnant Jehovah’s Witness teenager despite her religious objection to the procedure.

The decision was made by a supreme court authority late last month after Mercy Hospitals Victoria requested approval to perform an emergency transfusion if necessary.

The pregnant teenager had told doctors that a transfusion was against her religious beliefs. But doctors were concerned that girl’s “small stature” put her at increased risk of hemorrhaging.

Associate Professor Campbell Paul, a consultant child psychiatrist at Melbourne’s Royal Children’s Hospital, told the court that, while the girl had been clear and consistent in her refusal of a transfusion, she was significantly influenced in her decision by her family and community. “[She has] been through considerable disruption and trauma through her life” and had “transgressed a major value of her family and her community” by having pre-marital sex.

“You could imagine that she feels very frightened” and worried about “further punishment”, he said.

The girl’s mother said via a translator that to forcibly administer a transfusion would be akin to assault or rape. She said that she would always always seek medical treatment for her children when they were unwell, and that ‘‘it’s just this matter of blood transfusion that she is not able to agree with’’.

Justice Cameron Macaulay granted Mercy hospital the authority to give the girl a transfusion if necessary as “a last resort” but only if they first used all other strategies to stop the bleeding and obtained authority from two doctors.

“I’m not satisfied that [the girl] has the maturity to understand the consequences of her choice,” he said.

“I do not consider that allowing her, in effect, to choose to die … is in her best interests”.

Melbourne hospital given right to administer transfusion without consent
Creative commons
blood transfusions
jehovah’s witness
religious liberty