Donor offspring report from Australian Senate committee
Hi there,
As the business of
assisted reproductive technology becomes more and more widespread, more and
more people are asking whether it needs to be closely regulated by governments.
After all, as many as one baby in 20 or 25 are born from IVF in some countries.
Society has an interest in ensuring that health and human rights are protected.
However, the IVF
industry generally opposes government regulation, arguing that it is perfectly
capable of policing its own affairs. This viewpoint, however, was dowsed with a
bucket of cold water in this week’s report from a committee of the Australian
Senate on donor-conceived children. It found that
-
“some clinics are
being accredited, even when they are not following the [National Health and
Medical Research Council] Guidelines” -
“the accreditation
process appears to lack transparency” -
“anonymous
donations are still being used or accepted in clinics, in breach of the NHMRC
Guidelines” -
“this system of
industry regulation has failed donor conceived people”
While government regulation brings its own
problems, it seems clear that private clinics are more interested in profit
than in the rights of the children they usher into the world. Stiffer
regulations and a government ombudsman seem absolutely necessary. What do you think?
Cheers,
Michael Cook
Editor
More Stories
BioEdge has closed its doors
After 23 years, BioEdge ceased published in May 2024. Not that there isn't lots to report on and talk about,...
How liberal are American bioethicists?
There is growing acknowledgement of the fact that the backgrounds, ideas, and politics of American academics are out of step...
Doctors can be socialized to cooperate in morally despicable evil, says bioethicist
Bioethicist Carl Elliott seems to relish stirring up fellow bioethicists and the medical profession. In his latest book, The Occasional Human...
3 sperm donors from same family in Quebec have sired 600 children
Three men in Quebec from the same family have fathered more than 600 children by offering free sperm on the...
American IVF clinics are happily offering sex selection
The United States is one of the few countries where IVF sex selection is legal – and it is a...
Owner of castration website in UK found guilty of grievous bodily harm
“Enhancement” normally connotes adding powers beyond normal human functioning. However, there are dark kinds of enhancement which remove them. A...