Has neuroscience defeated moral relativism?
A.C. Grayling raves about mirror neurons
Somewhat like Darwinism, neuroscience is a field which is being mined for all the answers to all the questions about what it means to be human. A plethora of new books and articles claims that morality is biologically based. One was reviewed recently in Science, "The Neuroscience of Fair Play: Why We (Usually) Follow the Golden Rule", by Donald W. Pfaff. The author aims to present a possible neural and genetic basis for the Golden Rule, not very successfully, according to the reviewer.
The latest convert is British philosopher A.C. Grayling. He writes in the New Scientist that the existence of mirror neurons proves that moral relativism is wrong. These are cells which fire when we perceive the actions of others– smiling, yawning, weeping and so on. "This means that the ultimate basis for moral judgement is hard-wired, and therefore universal. So even when customs differ, fundamental morality does not," he says.
The existence of an objective morality has fewer and fewer defenders nowadays, but its champions may not wish to enlist Professor Grayling. A significant problem with his theory is that mirror neurons may not exist. They have been observed in macaque monkeys, but not in humans. It seems a bit early to close the file on moral relativism, on the basis of conflicting and tentative experimental results in a different species. ~ Science, May 2; New Scientist, May 3
More Stories
BioEdge has closed its doors
After 23 years, BioEdge ceased published in May 2024. Not that there isn't lots to report on and talk about,...
How liberal are American bioethicists?
There is growing acknowledgement of the fact that the backgrounds, ideas, and politics of American academics are out of step...
Doctors can be socialized to cooperate in morally despicable evil, says bioethicist
Bioethicist Carl Elliott seems to relish stirring up fellow bioethicists and the medical profession. In his latest book, The Occasional Human...
3 sperm donors from same family in Quebec have sired 600 children
Three men in Quebec from the same family have fathered more than 600 children by offering free sperm on the...
American IVF clinics are happily offering sex selection
The United States is one of the few countries where IVF sex selection is legal – and it is a...
Owner of castration website in UK found guilty of grievous bodily harm
“Enhancement” normally connotes adding powers beyond normal human functioning. However, there are dark kinds of enhancement which remove them. A...