Warnock offers advice in Nature
With the British Parliament deliberating the further liberalisation of its
fertility laws to allow hybrid human-animal embryos, the leading journal Nature
has sought guidance from the Grand Old Lady of British bioethics, Dame Mary
Warnock. Back in 1984 Dame Mary supervised the drafting of the original law
regulating fertility treatment and embryo experimentation.
In a special essay she argues that decisions about matters which some members
of the public may find repugnant must be guided by public morality, whose
principles differ from those of private morality. Religious considerations must
be overlooked as Britain is not "intrinsically religious". The appropriate
standard is "weighing up possible goods against possible harms" (which do not
include offending particular interest groups). The final decision should be made
by expert committees whose members are not guided by "ignorance and prejudice".
~ Nature, Nov 29
Author of IVF law says committees preserve from ignorance and prejudice
- How long can you put off seeing the doctor because of lockdowns? - December 3, 2021
- House of Lords debates assisted suicide—again - October 28, 2021
- Spanish government tries to restrict conscientious objection - October 28, 2021
More Stories
Is diversity of opinion at risk in medical journals?
A couple of years ago, a new editor was appointed to one of the world’s leading medical journals, JAMA, or...
It’s time to abolish morality in bioethics, say bioethicists
The idea that morality ought to be abolished is not limited to invading armies (pick one) or child abusers or...
Former deputy editor of BioEdge to head Sydney bioethics centre
The former deputy editor of BioEdge has been appointed director of a bioethics think tank in Australia. Dr Xavier Symons,...
The medical profession needs to reflect on the crimes of Nazi doctors, says The Lancet
Medical ethics education must be informed by a robust understanding of medicine’s role within the Nazi regime, according to a...
Is the ethics of animal liberation showing its age? Is Peter Singer a closet speciesist?
The Expanding Circle (1981) is one of Peter Singer’s best-known books. In it he argues that moral progress is marked...
The responsibility of bioethicists: the case study of Yemen
With the eyes of the world on the war between Israel and Hamas in Gaza, there have been relatively few...