
Paradoxes of assisted suicide in Germany
The status of assisted suicide in Germany is paradoxical: you have a right to assisted suicide but you do not have a right to acquire suicide drugs.
In 2020 a landmark ruling by the country’s highest court affirmed the radical autonomy of every German. Everyone therefore had a right to commit suicide and for someone to assist him. However, the procedures for doing this were not specified.
This week a court in Münster ruled that even if seriously ill people have a right to commit suicide and to be assisted, they do not have a right to acquire lethal medication.
The case before the court involved three chronically ill people who had asked the Federal Institute for Drugs and Medical Devices (BfArM) for permission to buy the drugs needed to die by suicide. But the court said that the BfArM was not “obliged to allow seriously ill people who have decided to commit suicide the purchase” of lethal medication.
These were not the only cases. So far the BfArM has rejected 225 requests for suicide-enabling medication.
The court declared that it is up to a democratically elected government to change the law on acquiring lethal drugs, but that in the meantime such a practice should remain illegal.
More Stories
Why not voluntary lawyer-assisted dying?
At an earlier stage in the debate over assisted dying, a critic wrote that it was incompatible with a physician’s...
South Australian prisoner will die through ‘voluntary assisted dying’
“Voluntary Assisted Dying” commenced in South Australia on January 31. The latest available figures show that 39 people have already...
Nitschke gets US tax-deductible status for his suicide machines
Americans can now get a tax-deduction for promoting assisted suicide. The world’s best-known assisted suicide activist, Australia’s Philip Nitschke, has...
Canadian man supplied 1200 suicide kits online
Canada, the country with the most victims of euthanasia, is also the home of a man who may have enabled...
Dutch court sentences man to 3½ years for assisting suicides
A Dutch court has sentenced a man to 3½ years in prison for providing contacts with a lethal suicide drug....
UK surgeons go ‘neutral’ on assisted dying
In a significant public relations victory for the assisted dying lobby in the United Kingdom, the Royal College of Surgeons...