IRS in sex-change surgery debate
The American tax office has been dragged into the debate over whether sex-changes are genuine medical treatment or an inappropriate response to a psychological problem. Rhianon O’Donnabhain, a construction engineer from Boston, decided to become a woman in 2001 after having fathered three children. He claimed a US$5,000 tax deduction for the surgery, which the Internal Revenue Service initially allowed. However, the IRS quickly reversed its decision because the operation had been merely cosmetic, and therefore not deductible. O’Donnabhain refused and sued the IRS. The case is now making its way through the courts.
O’Donnabhain, now 64, is supported by the Boston-based Gay and Lesbian Advocates and Defenders as a test case. A psychiatrist at Harvard Medical School, Marshall Forstein, says that an operation is clearly medically necessary. “When did the IRS suddenly become physicians? It’s absolutely clear that transgender identity is a condition discussed in diagnostic manuals. It seems the IRS is now in the business of practicing medicine without a licence.”
- How long can you put off seeing the doctor because of lockdowns? - December 3, 2021
- House of Lords debates assisted suicide—again - October 28, 2021
- Spanish government tries to restrict conscientious objection - October 28, 2021
More Stories
War and peace: Israeli physicians treating Palestinian patients
In the midst of the bitter war between Hamas and the Israeli Defense Forces in Gaza, there is a ray...
Court rules ‘voluntary assisted dying’ is suicide
Such is the stigma surrounding suicide that advocates of “voluntary assisted dying” insist vehemently that it is by no means...
Is poverty a cause of the rise of trans identity in the UK?
UK rates of transgender identity have risen at least 5-fold since 2000, with the highest rise observed among 16 to...
Donor anonymity becomes a battleground in the US
Donor-conceived Americans who want the federal government to abolish donor anonymity are getting pushback from the LGBTQI+ lobby. On the...
Should there be a ‘dead donor rule’ for sperm donation?
Sperm donation creates a web of exceedingly complex relationships. The HeyReprotech Newsletter (a great Substack resource for news about assisted...
The oldest mother in Africa is single and broke
A 70-year-old Ugandan woman has given birth to twins after receiving IVF treatment. Safina Namukwaya delivered a boy and a...