South African transplant surgeons cleared in epic court battle
Four South African surgeons have been cleared of involvement in a major international cash-for-kidneys scandal – but only after nearly ten years of prosecution.
Professor John Robbs, Dr Mahadev Naidoo, Professor Ariff Haffejee and Dr Neil Christopher, of Durban, said that they were “delighted that the charges against us have been finally and officially withdrawn.”
The surgeons, and two staff members were charged with complicity in 90 illegal kidney transplant operations between 2001 and 2003. Poor Brazilians and Romanians, some of them minors, sold their kidneys to wealthy Israeli patients. Netcare KwaZulu-Natal, the largest private hospital group in South Africa, pleaded guilty and was heavily fined.
The doctors said in a statement, “It is astounding that without one shred of credible evidence against us that this matter could have dragged on for approximately ten years. The damage to our health, reputations, professional careers, relationships with colleagues and professional bodies is immeasurable”.
Michael Cook
Creative commons
organ donation
South Africa
- Queensland legalises ‘assisted dying’ - September 19, 2021
- Is abortion a global public health emergency? - April 11, 2021
- Dutch doctors cleared to euthanise dementia patients who have advance directives - November 22, 2020
More Stories
War and peace: Israeli physicians treating Palestinian patients
In the midst of the bitter war between Hamas and the Israeli Defense Forces in Gaza, there is a ray...
Court rules ‘voluntary assisted dying’ is suicide
Such is the stigma surrounding suicide that advocates of “voluntary assisted dying” insist vehemently that it is by no means...
Is poverty a cause of the rise of trans identity in the UK?
UK rates of transgender identity have risen at least 5-fold since 2000, with the highest rise observed among 16 to...
Donor anonymity becomes a battleground in the US
Donor-conceived Americans who want the federal government to abolish donor anonymity are getting pushback from the LGBTQI+ lobby. On the...
Should there be a ‘dead donor rule’ for sperm donation?
Sperm donation creates a web of exceedingly complex relationships. The HeyReprotech Newsletter (a great Substack resource for news about assisted...
The oldest mother in Africa is single and broke
A 70-year-old Ugandan woman has given birth to twins after receiving IVF treatment. Safina Namukwaya delivered a boy and a...