
Mexico’s Supreme Court dismantles conscientious objection
The Supreme Court of Mexico is dismantling the right of doctors to conscientious objection, after its recent decision that the states must decriminalise abortion.
In its decision on September 20, eight members of the 11-member court declared that the exercise of women’s reproductive rights must not be thwarted by doctors who appeal to their consciences. Somewhat confusingly, it also asserted that conscientious objection was a constitutional right.
The president of the Supreme Court, Arturo Saldivar, explained in El Pais that “We cannot issue a blank cheque that denies health services, particularly the right to abortion.”
“Conservative and religious groups are pressuring this Court to recognise the right of unlimited conscientious objection because they know that this is the end of the right of women to have a dignified abortion,” Zaldívar said. “I find it unacceptable to recognise a right that women have struggled to win, and then allow its exercise to become bogged down in the hands of conscientious objectors and political groups.”
Pro-life groups have called for public protests.
- How long can you put off seeing the doctor because of lockdowns? - December 3, 2021
- House of Lords debates assisted suicide—again - October 28, 2021
- Spanish government tries to restrict conscientious objection - October 28, 2021
More Stories
Is the Spanish government creating a black list of healthcare workers who are conscientious objectors?
Euthanasia became legal in Spain on 25 June 2021. An unusual feature of its law is that the Health Ministry...
Do ‘conscientious providers’ matter more than ‘conscientious objectors’?
Dov Fox, an expert on health law and bioethics, has written a blistering attack on conscientious objection and a defence...
Seeking an ethical way to support pro-abortion doctors in anti-abortion states
The landscape of conscientious objection has changed. Back in 2006, when abortion was legal across the United States in the...
Catholic hospital could be forced to perform gender-affirming surgery
The University of Maryland St Joseph Medical Center violated federal law when it refused to provide gender-affirming surgical care to...
World Medical Association protects conscientious objection by rejecting mandatory referral
Principled conscientious objection (CO) for health care workers is under threat from laws in several jurisdictions around the world. A...
Should institutions enjoy freedom of conscience?
One of the most difficult issues in contemporary bioethics is “institutional freedom of conscience”. Should a healthcare facilities or nursing...