Mea culpas and they-a culpas
Therapeutic cloning on the skids
Here’s an interesting idea about the phenomenon of apologising for the sins
of past sins, from bioethicist Alice Dreger, of Northwestern
University. She is discussing an apology issued by the American Medical
Association for discriminating against African-American doctors.
"It’s more like a ‘they-a culpa,’ since the AMA administrators are actually
apologizing for bad behavior on the part of their predecessors. ‘They-a culpas’
can be just a wee bit self-serving… When you pull a ‘they-a culpa,’ you don’t
actually have to admit to any sin of your own, and you accrue all the social
capital of being decent enough to apologize…
[W]hat if, rather then just issuing a ‘they-a culpa,’ the AMA administrators
hired some historians to ask a really interesting question: What are we doing
right now that our successors are going to feel the need to apologize for? What
is the AMA doing now that might look later like racial discrimination looks to
us now?"
Good question. Any comments from BioEdge readers? ~ Bioethics
Forum, July 18
- How long can you put off seeing the doctor because of lockdowns? - December 3, 2021
- House of Lords debates assisted suicide—again - October 28, 2021
- Spanish government tries to restrict conscientious objection - October 28, 2021
More Stories
JAMA appoints new editor for new times
Last year, the Journal of the American Medical Association (JAMA) lost both its deputy editor and its editor. To rephrase...
Bioethics after Ukraine
In a thoughtful essay in The Hastings Center blog, Jonathan Moreno, a leading bioethicist, reflects on how bioethics will change...
Bioethics must repudiate its white past to confront racism
The Black Lives Matter movement has exposed a crisis in bioethics, argues Camisha Russell, of the University of Oregon, in...
Do critics of ‘conversion therapy’ live in a fact-free zone?
“We are committed to building a society in which conversion therapy no longer takes place,” says the UK Minister for...
Should psychiatrists revise their ‘Goldwater Rule’?
American psychiatrists are ethically barred from commenting on the mental health of public figures under the so-called Goldwater Rule. This...
‘Shit-stirring’ discredits utilitarianism, bioethicist argues
Utilitarianism has an image problem. Whether or not you agree with them, utilitarian arguments are widely used and need to...