Practical problems of ape personhood
Who will police them?
Conceding that apes
are persons could be expensive, says an Australian philosopher, as we would
have to police ape societies to prevent assault and murder. Writing in Oxford’s
Practical Ethics blog, Dr
Steve Clarke says that “If we take the idea that non human great apes have the
right to life then surely we have a responsibility to police all ape
communities to uphold the right to life, in the same way that we try to ensure
that the right to human life is upheld, by policing human societies.”
Two objections immediately arise. First, that it would be
too expensive. Chimpanzees and bonobos are a feisty lot and kill each other and
other apes. But, writes Dr Clarke, a person is a person, and refusing to
protect ape persons against violence would be “highly discriminatory”. One
solution would be to “redeploy police from the safest human communities to the
more violent ape communities.” Second, apes are wild animals and should not be
interfered with. This is understandable, he says, “But animals can only be wild
animals if humans don’t attempt to uphold their rights.” ~ Practical
Ethics, Feb 26
- How long can you put off seeing the doctor because of lockdowns? - December 3, 2021
- House of Lords debates assisted suicide—again - October 28, 2021
- Spanish government tries to restrict conscientious objection - October 28, 2021
Media approaches peak cognitive dissonance over the ‘T’ in LGBT Pride month
The media is approaching peak cognitive dissonance in Pride Month over the issue of transgenderism. On the one hand, Glamour...
The Economist: ‘Global fertility has collapsed’
The Economist, an oracle for politicians, journalists, and economists the world over, has turned bearish on the future of humanity....
Croatia plans to import sperm. No one back home wants to donate
Sperm and egg donation has been legal in Croatia since 2012. But no one has donated. The problem seems to...
Australian woman freed after 20 years after new genetic evidence raised ‘reasonable doubt’
An Australian woman who spent 20 years in jail for murdering her four infant children has been pardoned on the...
Is surrogacy a way of combatting ‘compulsory familialism’?
For people on either side of the debate, surrogacy can seem like a black-and-white issue. Opponents stress human dignity; supporters...
The FDA finally approved Elon Musk’s Neuralink chip for human trials. Have all the concerns been addressed?
Since its founding in 2016, Elon Musk’s neurotechnology company Neuralink has had the ambitious mission to build a next-generation brain...